Keynote: Rewilding voice in a time of enclosure

In a world of feeds full of algorithmic reels and AI slop, what does it mean to write for ourselves? In a post-RSS, post-social media era, how do we navigate the enclosure and weaponization of the platforms that once networked the voices of the open web? And if we *do* push through the journey of crafting our own voices, our own narratives…does the breakdown of networks and fracturing of the open web mean our voices will echo, unheard?ย  This session is aimed at tracing the sociomaterial shifts in what writing online has meant over the last 15-20 years, and convening a social, back-and-forth discussion via Mentimenter. It will explore and poll participants’ experiences and feelings about the various questions posed, and what answers and suggestions we can muster, as a collective. It will explore what’s been lost, but also what possibilities remain when the web is viewed as what Ursula Franklin called a ‘holistic technology’…as opposed to the prescriptive technologies that enclosure and automation offer us. The session will focus on ‘re-wilding’ ideas of voice and a commons even within our polluted information ecosystem, and on building capacity to connect with each other and to value each other’s voices.

Session Author(s):

bstewart

Session Resources:

Comments Archive

reclaimhosting: Welcome to the Chat
Jim Groom: Looking forward to this talk from Bonnie. The title is worth the price of admissions. Rock, not rot!
taylorjadin: WOO! Keynote time
Readywriting: HI BONNIE I MISS YOU!
Martin: Howdy Bonnie!
Alan: Yay
Jason: Excited for the keynote. Hi Bonnie! Thanks for being here.
Alan: Where's the washrooms?
Lorna: Hi Bonnie, Maren ๐Ÿ˜Š
maren: Here is the link to mentimeter https://www.mentimeter.com/
Joe Murphy: Woohoo! (Will be referring to that Blogging COP session in my session later today...)
maren: 89988444
Jim Groom: 8998844
Tim Klapdor: *Waves in Australian*
Jim Groom: I am missing a 4
Tom Witherspoon: Hello from PDX!
Tim Klapdor: Yes it is the future here!
Martin: @jim that's not all you're missing to be fair ;)
Joe Murphy: Hey Tom!
Mark: Los Angeles
Alan: I seem to be filtered out
Alan: Just delayed
Jeanine Finn: Gen X is feeling all that
Rushaw: We still have cat gifs at Reclaim Open 2025
Stephen Downes: Hola
Jason: GenX4Life
Joe Murphy: "Tell your dog i said hi"
Stephen Downes: Generation Jones ftw
maren: If you are just joining, play along using code 89988444 at https://www.mentimeter.com/
taylorjadin: https://media.tenor.com/MRCIli40TYoAAAAj/under-construction90s-90s.gif
Alan: Moar dog gifs
Lorna: Love the Fail Whale.
Martin: I am here for a pure nostalgia chat btw
Joe Murphy: Oooh Guthrie!
Tom Witherspoon: Still missing the Thin White Duke!
Stephen Downes: I know the feeling. If I sing, people ask me to stop.
Jason: everyone can sing...maybe not well...but don't let that stop you!
Alan: https://cogdogblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/drbon-cover.jpg
taylorjadin: "in the world" is hard for me. I don't feel like I have a unique voice in any public sense. but in small circles, with friends, maybe?
Alan: From a rewrite of Major Tom as "โ€œAll of Twitter to #DrBonโ€" https://soundcloud.com/cogdogroo/all-of-twitter-to-drbon
Pilot: @Taylor Funnily enough the first thing that jumped to mind was streaming about Obsidian on Reclaim TV
Tom Witherspoon: Bravo!
Pilot: Wasn't sure if that counted but seeing everyone else's answers is changing my mind
taylorjadin: @pilot Yeah for sure, I suppose thats true. I do feel strongly about talking about open source tools etc. I used to consider music as a part of "my voice" but not really right now, as I'm not creative in that space right now. I should work on that I think.
maren: I had one of these, too (the school house)
Alan: I miss so much using Martin Hawksey's TwitterTAGs visualizer of hashtag activity
maren: @Alan I chatted with him yesterday and shared some of our chat. He waves hello
Scottish Nomad: @alan So do I!
Tim Klapdor: Love a good chat about enclosure!
Joe Murphy: *with an asterisk by the word "glorious"...
Readywriting: Look out for a new Data-Sitters Club book on our thoughts and feelings about AI! Coming soon!
Pilot: No room for 2 out of 3? The perks of dystopia... XD
Stephen Downes: I think it's a work in progress, only a part of the wider picture of AI, and potentially very useful
Joe Murphy: 100%!
taylorjadin: I'd like to answer 2/3 not so much glorious future, but certainly a nightmare and sometimes useful
Readywriting: OH MY GOD AM I EVER.
taylorjadin: definitely sick of the hype
Rushaw: Sick!
Stephen Downes: I'm not, keep the AI im,provbements coming
Readywriting: I wish we could just stop.
maren: 100%
Lorna: Yeah, pretty much.
Readywriting: It's taking up all the oxygen.
Christina Hendricks: I'm really interested in how the pervasiveness of AI and AI talk is leading us to think more about the value of human relationships.
Stephen Downes: Large corporations and income inequality is the threat - if it weren't for that we'd think very differently about AI
Scottish Nomad: So a bunch of us including Bon just had this published: AI Surveillance in Education: Unpacking Ethical Dilemmas and the Snake-Oil Promises of AI-Infused Technosolutionism https://www.igi-global.com/chapter/ai-surveillance-in-education/392857
Stephen Downes: No, that's a misrepresentation of AI
Readywriting: SAY IT LOUDER FOR THOSE IN THE BACK
Stephen Downes: That's just a misues of AI, not a property of AI
Stephen Downes: Put anything at the centre and you get the same result
Mark: Dave White: Digital Education https://daveowhite.com/about/
Alan: Marketing strategy
Alan: And the long tail has been squashed?
Stephen Downes: The University of the District of Columbia (UDC) needed to find a way to reduce operational costs across nine locations to reallocate more resources to enhancing the student experience. Read the case study to see how Xeroxยฎ Managed Print Services helped them do just that. With Xeroxยฎ Managed Print Services, UDC is printing more efficiently and effectively. Students can print where and when they want, and more resources are being kept in the classroom. https://www.xerox.ca/en-ca/services/manag…
Stephen Downes: The same strategy applies to all industries across the board - the problem is the model, not the specific tech
Alan: "too small to be found"?
maren: I really appreciate the thoughtful approach Bonnie is presenting
jim luke: Alan, there is no long -tail that's feasible and profitable. The "marketing strategies" now for AI are to keep the bubble looking feasible a little longer so the last stages of the ponzi-investors can be persuaded to invest before the bubble pops, and most all lose all they put in.
Stephen Downes: I too appreciaste her thoughtfulness, but I think she's wrong
maren: @alan that's a nice way of putting it
Alan: @jim indeed, but is profit everyone's goal?
Jeanine Finn: I don't think the tech and the model are separable when it comes to AI* (a marketing term, after all)
Stephen Downes: Real estate is (mostly) a long-tail business - having millions and millions of property-owners instead of a few large owners that own everything (btw we need to take steps to preserve that)
Jim Groom: Love that ds106radio gets a shot out...#4life! I hope Grant Potter is listening :)
Stephen Downes: (fwiw if there are no good long tail business models, then enclsurte and centralized ownership is inevitable (which we don't want))
Alan: Small conversations.
Alan: My menti is stuck
Scottish Nomad: Some of us never stopped being in the wild ...
Alan: Forever wild
Alan: individual conversations, go for the small stage, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GOrdzCHnpw4
Joe Murphy: Did it just get dusty in here? There's something in my eyes...
Alan: There's some guy out there who spontaneously calls me on the phone.
Scottish Nomad: Born to be wild https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=egMWlD3fLJ8
Jason: great poem...i def do not read enough poetry these days
taylorjadin: ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘
Alan: Love the CLMOOC postcard "program"
Jim Groom: Thank tou very much, Bonnie! You even got fireworks in the UK ;)
Lorna: Wonderful. Thank you Bonnie.
Robert: thank you
Joe Murphy: ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘
Tim Klapdor: Lol fireworks to end! Amazing
Jeanine Finn: thank you!
Pilot: This was awesome!
Rushaw: Thank you, Bonnie!
Christina Hendricks: This talk (and yesterday'nspiring me to go back to blogging
Stephen Downes: (I saw a sign at Occupy Wall Street: Too Small To Fail)
Jason: Me too @christina
Alan: Do things with your own hands.
Christina Hendricks: This talk and yesterday's blog-a-thon are inspiring me to get back to writing on my blog. Voices matter!
Scottish Nomad: #blogging4life
Jason: I am not leaving traces of my voice anywhere!
Pilot: @Jason ds106radio would beg to differ
Jason: I was just goona say...except DS106 Radio
Alan: Hah! @stephen I want that sign "Too Small To Fail"
Joe Murphy: @Christina I wanted to let you know that somewhere I found a ds106radio bumper you did back in the day and i still use it every now and then. Thanks for your voice!
Christina Hendricks: Oh, that's fantastic, Joe--thanks for letting me know! I had so much fun in the day making bumpers!
Jim Groom: @jason we are the better for it, your lunchtime show was magic.
Martin: applause - thanks for the inspiration Bonnie
Joe Murphy: @christina then go make me another one. ๐Ÿ˜‚
Readywriting: WOOOOO!!!!!!
Christina Hendricks: Thank you thank you thank you!
Carmen Vallis: Thanks so much Bonnie
Joe Murphy: THANK YOU!
Jason: Thanks for a great hour of contemplation.
Jim Groom: Thanks again, and the interactive piece through Mentimeter was fun!
Readywriting: <3 <3 <3
Rushaw: ๐Ÿ˜
Mark: Thanks to all!
Tierney Steelberg: Thank you so much โ€“ this was fantastic and much-needed today.
Lorna: โ™กโ™กโ™ก